‘The Traitors: New Blood’ Exit Interview: Ben McDonnell on Clocking Every Traitor and the Move He Wishes He Made

Ben McDonnell

It had certainly Ben a Week for Ben McDonnell when his time in the castle came to an end. The actor and host of the aptly titled podcast It’s Ben a Week quietly built one of the most impressive voting records on The Traitors: New Blood. By the time he was murdered, he had helped banish two Traitors and become the only Faithful to cast at least one vote against every Traitor in the game.

Ben earned everyone’s trust and never received a vote at the roundtable, but playing such a clean game ultimately made him a target for murder. Looking back, he wishes he had created more suspicion around himself or made one final pitch to Katie Fites: recruit him, and he would help keep the other players from coming after her.

Pop Culturalist chatted with Ben about clocking every Traitor, the move he wishes he had made, and why playing too Faithfully cost him the game. He also discussed hiding his acting career and the unexpected friendships he formed in the castle.

PC: You went out of the game on such a high, banishing two Traitors and becoming the only Faithful to cast at least one vote against every Traitor in the game by the time you were murdered. Had you survived, was your plan to continue building a case against Katie, or were you hoping the pressure you were putting on her might convince her to recruit you?
Ben: Of course, I wanted to be recruited. That would have been the dream. After we banished Joe, part of me wanted to tell her, “Listen, recruit me. I’ll help you. I’ll make sure these boys don’t come for you.” But that could have backfired so easily. I didn’t know which way to go, but obviously, I should have done it. I should have been like, “Listen, I know you’re a Traitor. Recruit me. We’ll spin this up.”

PC: One of the greatest challenges of being a Faithful is that you have to prove yourself and build enough trust that you don’t become a target at the roundtable, but not so much that you become a target for murder. How did you try to navigate that impossible balance? Did you ever consider intentionally raising suspicion around yourself to lower your threat level with the Traitors?
Ben: Yeah! There was a point in the game when I was walking around the castle, and I was like, “Will someone please write my name down? Please. Can we get a little heat?” Not one person wrote my name down.

There was one moment when Wyatt [Gillespie] was like, “Man, Ben, maybe you’re a Traitor because you’re funny.” I literally said, “I’m not a Traitor, and I’m sorry you’re not.” But I had no heat on me the entire season. It was crazy to me.

So, yes, I wish I could go back and play more like Jay [Vinnedge]. I wish I had stirred something up. Kriste [Lewis] went after Madeline [Kostopulos] at that first roundtable and then flew under the radar. I wish I had done something like that because I think I was just so obviously Faithful.

PC: That’s such a great point. Kriste, Jay, and, to some extent, Victor [Vollbrechthausen] had so much heat on them early in the game, but it died down as the season progressed. I think one reason was that there were so many twists added this season. They brought a fun new layer to the game, but I can imagine they made things harder for you as a player, especially because there wasn’t always a clear explanation for why someone was murdered. How much did that complicate your ability to understand the reasoning behind the murders and narrow down your suspects?
Ben: When you’re playing a game like this, you know what you’re getting into, so you’re on high alert at all times. You’re always watching. In the episode when Mark [Zgoda] was murdered, I immediately clocked Katie [Fites]. I was like, “You’re so calm.” You start to notice different things.

When you’re playing this game, you really only spend time with one another, so you become fast friends. You really do. I used to watch the show and think, “Why are these people crying? They’ve known each other for a week.” But you really do start to form genuine friendships with these people. You’re always on edge and trying to keep an eye on what’s going on.

As a viewer, you have all the answers. You know who the Traitors are, and you get a bird’s-eye view because you see what’s happening in every room. If I’m in the kitchen, I don’t know what they’re doing outside. I don’t know what someone is saying about me in their confessional. I don’t know who’s working together. When you’re playing the game, it’s much harder, and things don’t seem nearly as obvious as they do when you’re watching it. Trust me, I’m watching the show like you guys and thinking, “How did we not see that? How did we miss this?” When you’re in it, it’s a completely different experience.

PC: Speaking of those connections, one of the most moving moments of the season was hearing you open up about never feeling like one of the boys. You expanded on that moment on your podcast, which is a great listen. What did it mean to share that part of yourself? As you learned everyone’s “why,” did it become more difficult to separate those personal connections from your strategy in the game?
Ben: Unlike some of my other cast members, whose tears may have been a little fabricated, my tears were definitely real. That was a very raw and honest moment for me because I’m a pretty funny, laid-back guy. I don’t get emotional very often, especially on national television in front of millions of viewers. That moment was very real and almost healing because I went into this experience not expecting to make friends. I thought we were just going to play this game.

As a gay guy who grew up in a small town in Wisconsin, I never had a bunch of guy friends. I was never included in a group with the boys. As a gay man, I’ve always naturally gravitated toward women. About 99% of my friends are female.

I even said in some of my press interviews that I was going to be the girls’ gay best friend and that the guys would see me as an asset because I could do the challenges. Yes, I was friends with all the women in there, but I wasn’t expecting to become friends with the guys. To this day, I still text and talk with most of them. It was a really cool experience.

As far as strategy, being a Faithful, it didn’t really change anything for me. But if I had been a Traitor and listened to some of these people’s stories, like Abbey [Benjamin] and Shane [Beatty], I think the guilt would have started to build.

PC: I want to go back a little earlier in the game and talk about you and the Dolls. You and Michael [Foote] sacrificed money from the prize pot to earn information about the Traitors, which felt like such a smart move, especially early on when there was so little concrete evidence to go on. But that decision ultimately led you to suspect Michael. Was there ever a conversation among the Dolls about keeping your suspicions under wraps and away from the roundtable, knowing that if Michael was a Traitor, he might continue protecting you in the turret?
Ben: First off, that clue sucked. When they told me it was a clue that would help me identify a Traitor, I expected it to be something concrete, like, “Their first name starts with a J.” Instead, it was a clue about something that happened when no one even knew what had happened. So let’s set the record straight on that. The clue was terrible.

But with Michael, there were many reasons why we started to think he was a Traitor. I know what you saw was me saying that he was smart, but I also caught him in a bunch of lies. He was very confident. How can you be confident in this game if you’re a Faithful?

Yes, Victor is a strong player. He went after the Traitors with everything he had, but he was still scared. Victor was afraid of being murdered. Even during the poisoned chalice, he was like, “I’m going to get murdered. I’m gone.” He was playing for his life. Michael was just like Katie. They were calm, cool, and collected.

To be fair, I’m watching it back now, and I still think he might be a Traitor. [Laughs] Is he a secret Traitor we don’t know about? But if he had been a Traitor, he probably would have killed one of us Dolls because that would have been a great move. He could have said, “I would never kill someone in my group.”

There were many reasons why we suspected him. It wasn’t just me who voted for Michael. He received a lot of votes at that roundtable.

PC: You’re an actor, and so much of your craft is rooted in understanding people, their motivations, and their perspectives. Did playing this game change the way you read others? Has the experience informed your creative process in any unexpected ways?
Ben: This was one of the most challenging acting experiences of my life because, yes, I was myself. You saw the real Ben, but I also had to act because I couldn’t let anyone know I was an actor or that I had a podcast.

When you show up on set, you’re portraying a character, but the director says, “Cut,” and you go back to being yourself. There is no “cut” when you’re playing The Traitors. You’re in character the entire time.

The other challenge is that the people around you aren’t playing characters. When you’re acting in a scene with someone, everyone is playing a role. We’re all pretending and playing. In this game, you’re seeing people for who they really are or who they want you to believe they are. I was very thankful for all my improv training at the Groundlings.

To keep up with Ben, follow him on Instagram. Stream The Traitors: New Blood on Peacock today.

Kevin

Kevin is a writer living in New York City. He is an enthusiast with an extensive movie collection, who enjoys attending numerous conventions throughout the year. Say hi on Twitter and Instagram!

Discussion about this post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.