Exit Interview: ‘The Traitors: New Blood’ Star Niyyah Bilal Hayes on Her Main-Character Murder and Being Her
Niyyah Bilal Hayes was made for reality television. Quick-witted, magnetic, and completely unafraid to speak her mind, she brought an unmistakable presence to The Traitors: New Blood. Whether she was challenging inconsistencies at the roundtable, building relationships throughout the castle, or delivering the kind of confessionals that instantly became memorable, Niyyah understood how to command a room without losing sight of the social game she came to play. After watching her play, there’s no disputing it: she’s her.
That social capital made her one of the season’s most fascinating players. Despite being vocal in a game where speaking too loudly can make someone an easy target, Niyyah earned the trust of both the Faithfuls and the Traitors. In fact, Joe Vanella and Tomica Adams had no intention of murdering her until a failed murder in plain sight left them with one final option: an apple, a last-second Hail Mary, and what Niyyah rightfully describes as a “main-character death.”
Pop Culturalist chatted with Niyyah Bilal Hayes about the hidden pressures of playing The Traitors: New Blood, why she always stood behind the arguments she made at the roundtable, the social strategy that kept her protected, her suspicions about Tomica, and the fateful apple that brought her game to an unforgettable end.
PC: When you’re watching The Traitors unfold on TV, it can seem so easy to put the clues together and figure out whom to trust, but it’s a completely different experience when you’re actually in the castle. How did the reality of playing the game compare to your expectations? What surprised you most about the experience?
Niyyah: What you don’t understand from watching is how stressful it is. I thought it was going to be smooth sailing. I’m a talker. I thought, “I’m going to work my way through these people. I’m going to read them and their personalities.” No. You’re up for around twelve hours a day. You’re hungry and exhausted. Literally anything anyone does puts you on edge.
You have to find people you trust, put your faith in them, and hope that’s enough because it’s not a game you can play by yourself. But it’s a double-edged sword because you may be cozying up to a Traitor.
PC: I feel like you were building a lot of social capital. With this being the first civilian season, you and your fellow contestants are setting the tone for how the game will be played in the future. How do you think the strategies and gameplay this season will influence the way future contestants approach the game?
Niyyah: When people apply to be on the next season, they’re going to think, “We’re going to be smarter than them.” Where we missed the mark this season was being so friendly with one another from the beginning. There wasn’t a lot of keeping our guards up. It was like, “Oh my gosh, we’re a family.” For the people going in next season, you’re not a family! Your Uncle Joe [Vanella] is going to murder you. He’s going to kill you. Don’t trust Uncle Joe or your mother, Tomica [Adams].
PC: You were talking about the stress of the game. The Faithfuls have yet to successfully identify a Traitor. I imagine that takes a toll as the game continues. How did those repeated setbacks affect the group’s morale and your own mindset heading into each roundtable, especially as the numbers started to dwindle?
Niyyah: Disheartening is the kindest and easiest way to put it because I helped spearhead the charge to send Arisa [Thomas] home over the hand-holding thing with Victor [Vollbrechthausen]. Then she gets up there and is like, “You guys are dumb. I’m not a Traitor.” You start second-guessing yourself, which isn’t helpful because you really need to follow your gut.
That’s why it’s so sad watching Victor talk about this apple. I’m like, “Guys, he’s talking. He’s talking. He’s talking. Somebody clock in and listen to this man. I know we didn’t listen to him in the past. I know I didn’t.” I gave Victor a lot of sh*t. You don’t see it on TV, but I was always like, “I don’t trust you, sweaty man.” [laughs] I think everyone needs to be much more guarded going forward than we were.
I also think it’s funny when people are like, “Didn’t these people watch the show?” Yeah, we watched the show, but it’s never been twenty-two people who didn’t know one another. It’s been Lisa Rinna and Rob [Rausch]. You’re obsessed with them. You can’t be obsessed with me because you don’t know me.
PC: You bring up such a great point. Victor’s observation about the fruit actually had legitimacy behind it. Do you think no one took it seriously because it came from Victor? If another Faithful had raised it, do you think the group would have given the theory more consideration?
Niyyah: I 100% think it was because it came from Victor. If Abby [Lee] had said it, people would have believed her. You watched us listen to Abby L. every single time, and she was dead wrong every single time. I love the girl, but she was dead wrong every single time. I was marching behind her like, “Yes, Abby L.! Yes!”
Once you lose even a shred of credibility in the castle, it’s very hard to come back from that. With Victor, there was the shield, the flirting, and all that other stuff. He’s a great guy, but once you no longer have people behind you, it’s very difficult to get anyone to listen to you.
PC: Something I really appreciated about you is that you always held people accountable at the roundtable, particularly Jay [Vinnedge], when you called out the inconsistency between the names he was throwing out and the person he ultimately voted for. There’s such a delicate balance to navigate at the roundtable. If you’re too vocal, you become a target. If you’re too quiet, it raises suspicions. How did you strike that balance and build your social capital? What would your strategy have been in those conversations had you not been murdered?
Niyyah: For me, you have to maintain the same personality when you get to the roundtable. If you haven’t been talking all day, why are you suddenly yapping at the roundtable? Then again, like you said, you can’t be too quiet because look at Sherry [Kuehl]. She’s gone because the one day she spoke up, everyone was like, “That’s weird.” It’s a very delicate balance, but my approach was to put my money where my mouth was.
When Arisa got up there and gave her whole speech, I was like, “Man, I don’t think she’s a Traitor.” But I wasn’t going to sit there, present evidence against someone, and then not stand ten toes down on what I had said. It irritated me to no end. We spent around 45 minutes listening to Jay’s monologue, and then he had the nerve to be like, “Sherry, go home.” Boy, get out of my face. Get out of my face! I can’t do it.
PC: Also, early in the game, there’s so little information to work with. I feel like there was a legitimate case against Arisa.
Niyyah: Right! I said that in the moment. I was like, “You guys are being weird. Why are you touching each other? We met a day ago.” But again, she’s literally the sweetest person ever. I felt so bad, but if I’m going to bring evidence to the roundtable and make a case against someone, I’m going to stand behind it. I’m a woman of my word.
PC: Looking back at the murder in plain sight, you weren’t Joe or Tomica’s intended target. But when their initial attempt didn’t work, it came down to a Hail Mary. Knowing how it all unfolded, were there any clues in the moment that you wish you had picked up on?
Niyyah: No. I know I keep saying this, but it looks like it should have been so easy to figure out. That day, I had never been in the same room as any of the people who had apples thrown at them. I had no clue Fruitgate was happening.
What you didn’t see was that Victor thought I was a Traitor, so he wasn’t going to tell me that people were throwing apples because he didn’t trust me. Wyatt [Gillespie] had also accused me the night before. I thought I was safe because people were beginning to suspect that I was a Traitor. I was also close to Joe and Tomica, so I was like, “I know Tomica’s going to take me to the end. She needs the numbers.”
Looking back, I guess it was weird that I dropped it. But I’m not going to let the Birds, the Philadelphia Eagles, down. This is not an interception. Absolutely not. I can truly say I have no regrets. I mean, my one regret is that I caught the apple. But would I have changed anything else? No. I was building a lot of social capital.
Who else have they murdered or banished only for two Traitors to say, “I can’t believe Niyyah’s gone. Why would you send her home?” I’m her. I hate to say it, but I really did have a main-character death. It’s nothing less than I deserved.
PC: You are definitely her. You were so vocal at the roundtables, and the Traitors still never wanted to murder you. It just happened the way it happened.
Niyyah: It was the luck of the draw.
PC: I don’t know why that apple was so difficult for everyone to catch.
Niyyah: Right? Come on. I always thought it would be my attitude or my mouth that sent me home, not my “athleticism.” I should go out there and get drafted.
PC: I give you so much credit. Usually, at the end of the roundtable, people mope, commiserate, and say, “We’ll get them next time.” But you spoke up and said, “You’re not putting any weight behind your words.”
Niyyah: Exactly! I had been very nice to him. I listened to him every time he went on one of his chaotic, neurotic rants. But we can’t keep doing this, babe. You’re derailing the program. You’re not bigger than the program. The program is to catch the Traitors.
If you’re constantly trying to paint yourself as the main character, I love that for you, but no one is going to listen to you. That means you’re just another mouth at the table eating off everyone else. You’re staying safe by being chaotic. It’s a strategy, but it’s not one I would have used. I don’t think I would have survived if I had done all that, but kudos to him. I can’t talk too much sh*t because he’s still there. So, kudos to him.
PC: There was a moment right before you were buried when Joe told you that he had to make that decision. Did you ever consider pulling a “Yam Yam” [Arocho] and shouting that Joe was a Traitor?
Niyyah: No. I was sad. I couldn’t believe that was how my time in the game ended. I was also pissed that he spent the entire time we were underground, with a spider hanging over my head, trying to get me to forgive him. I was like, “Shut up. I’ll forgive you in about three months.” We’re fine now.
There was a moment when I considered it, but I don’t want to get blacklisted by NBC. This girl needs to get on TV again.
PC: They need to bring you back for another show.
Niyyah: I have to follow the rules. If that happens again, don’t ask for forgiveness until I’m ready.
PC: Listen, we’ve got at least two more seasons. Maybe they’ll bring you back for All-Stars. You and Tomica had a really close relationship. She even shared that she would have taken you to the end. Was there ever a point when you started to suspect her? There comes a time in the game when you have to question why you’re still there and whether someone might have a reason to keep you around.
Niyyah: Yes. On the first day, I asked her, “Are you a Traitor?” I was like, “This is giving me hives.” She said, “If this is giving you hives, I don’t know what it’s giving me.”
There was definitely a moment when I thought, “She’s too calm and collected.” I know you’re a pilot. I know you’re older. But she would say, “Maybe we’re going to die today,” and I’d be like, “Girl, I’m shaking in my boots.” She was always so cool and collected.
But I wasn’t going to make my suspicions known because my strategy was to play a social game. I thought the more people who liked me and the more alliances I had, the further I would get. If I hadn’t caught that apple, I genuinely think I would have been there much longer.
To keep up with Niyyah, follow her on Instagram. The Traitors: New Blood is currently airing on NBC and available to stream the next day on Peacock.
Discussion about this post