‘The Traitors: New Blood’ Exit Interview: Joe Vanella on Building Social Capital, Fruitgate, and Creating a Loyal Turret

Joe Vanella

Joe Vanella understood that the most valuable currency in The Traitors: New Blood was not information, but trust. From the moment he entered the castle, he invested in relationships across the house, building the kind of social capital that made him one of the most influential players in the game. Even as suspicion began to follow him, few Faithfuls were willing to say his name too loudly.

That hesitation became one of Joe’s greatest weapons. Murdered and banished players repeatedly revealed that they had suspected him, yet they understood the risk of coming after someone so well-connected without the numbers to finish the job. Accusing Joe and missing could alienate the house and place an immediate target on their backs. By making himself both liked and trusted, he created a protective barrier that allowed him to shape votes, eliminate the game’s strongest voices, and keep the Faithfuls focused elsewhere.

Pop Culturalist chatted with Joe about building social capital, orchestrating Fruitgate, and creating a loyal turret that refused to turn on one another. He also discussed the emotional weight of murdering players he had grown to love, his decision to protect Tomica Adams, and why he would play the exact same game if invited back for an All-Stars season.

PC: I feel like future Traitors need to study your strategy. Time and time again, murdered and banished Faithfuls said they suspected you, but you built so much social capital that they could never rally the numbers to vote you out. Were you aware of the power you had in the castle? How did you earn their trust so quickly?
Joe: I love you for picking up on that. Everybody’s been like, “What’s he doing in there?” I knew my strongest suit was my social game. I knew that 100%. My entire game was about building trust with everybody. There’s an old saying: “If people like you, they’ll listen to you. If they trust you, they’ll do business with you.” At that point, I felt like I had climbed that ladder.

Everybody was talking about Victor [Vollbrechthausen] and Victor getting to me, but the fact is, Victor’s game and mine were polar opposites. I had a lot of social currency. He didn’t. So I played that game. The Traitors is more social than any other game in the reality TV spectrum. It was very important for me to build that trust and bank that social capital.

PC: Definitely. You had your fellow players in tears as they were voting to banish you. Speaking of Victor, you voted for him at three separate roundtables. Why didn’t you just murder him?
Joe: This comes back to the social game. Let’s not forget, everybody’s like, “He’s playing a great game.” Somebody said he’s one of the best Faithfuls ever. I think that’s up for debate. He had the fruit thing, which was a great catch, but his social game was trash. His social game was my physical game. My physical game was garbage.

As far as I’m concerned, the man was banished. We shouldn’t have had to murder him. At that point, when Shane [Beatty] saved him by some miracle of Alan [Cumming] making up this rule to keep him in the game, murdering him would have put a lot of heat on Tomica [Adams].

Then, with the chalice coming, I knew Morgan [Cook] was coming after me at the next roundtable. I could out-argue Victor, and I feel like I did, at least, but he had the Dolls’ votes. If Morgan had spoken up and come after me, it would have carried a lot more social weight. I felt I had a better chance of outmaneuvering Victor than Morgan.

PC: Great strategic move. About halfway through the game, it seemed like the Traitors had everything under control and a clear path to the end. How did the Faithfuls being so far off influence your strategy, particularly when it came to whom you murdered and which players were more valuable to keep around?
Joe: The Faithfuls being off was part of our gameplay. I think the fact that you had three very charismatic Traitors helped keep them off our scent. When we took out Mark [Zgoda], we knew it would be a morale killer. You saw it at breakfast. We sat there for five minutes and didn’t say a word. So it accomplished what we wanted it to.

Abby Lee gets way too much hate online. She played a great game. She played it the way you’re supposed to. She was naming names and wasn’t afraid to interrogate people. Even though she was my friend, she was smart enough that I knew she would eventually come for me. It was the same with Morgan.

People also wondered about Logan [Smith]. We sent Logan home because he could control the roundtable. When Jay [Vinnedge] was in chaos mode, Logan would get us back on course. We needed him gone so we could allow the chaos to run wild at the roundtable.

PC: That’s also why you got rid of Kim [Daily] early on.
Joe: Kim was too strong. I spoke with Kim, rode in the Landy with her, and sat with her on the train. I thought she was going to be such a strong player and such a big voice that she had to go immediately. She was also next to me when I got the tap. I’ll tell you, I stopped breathing at that point. I was like, “She heard me. She’s got to go.”

PC: You’re so calculated, Joe. You were a fan of the game going into it. After murdering Niyyah Bilal Hayes, you immediately told her you were responsible and apologized. There were so many moments, like the dinners where everyone shared why they were competing, that made the game much more personal. Were you surprised by the emotional toll of being a Traitor? How did you separate those relationships from the game, and how much did you rely on Tomica and Katie [Fites] in those moments?
Joe: It was tough. Like you said, I’m a fan first. When I saw Traitors struggling with murders, I was like, “Stop. That’s why we’re all here.” But then you live it, and you start loving these people. You form these trauma bonds with everyone in the castle. Then you have to send them home, knowing why each person is there and that you’re taking that opportunity away from them. It sucks.

The fact that we had such a loyal turret was important. That’s something Tomica and I wanted. We could lift each other up whenever one of us was down. If I was feeling bad, Tomica would be like, “Let’s get back on track.” If Katie was hurting, I’d go to her. If either of us needed support, Katie would rally around us and keep morale up. We were lucky to have the Traitor group we did because it just worked.

PC: The Traitors seemed committed to reaching the end together, but after you orchestrated Fruitgate and Tomica ultimately took the blame for it, did you ever consider letting her take the fall to protect your own game?
Joe: I really didn’t want to. I’ve heard some people say that I defended her too much, but I wanted to keep the three of us together until the end. The biggest thing we told each other was that if the heat ever became too much, we shouldn’t be afraid to pull the cord. At that final roundtable, when they got her, it was obvious she was going home. One of the worst parts of the game was writing her name down. I did not want to do that.

PC: It felt like a game move you had to make. Going into your final roundtable, you needed six votes to stay. Whose support did you believe you had, or did you already have a sense that you were going home? If you had survived, what was your strategy moving forward?
Joe: I knew that Jay knew I was a Traitor. He alluded to it during our conversation on the lawn, but he was like, “I’m not going to write your name down.” What I didn’t know was that Victor had the Dolls voting as a bloc. I had no idea because I didn’t know how tight Victor and Ben [McDonnell] were. Once that happened, I knew I was dead in the water.

But there was a moment when I was arguing and thought, “I’ve got this.” I felt like I had put enough heat on Wyatt [Gillespie]. We had already discussed Wyatt, so I thought it might come back around to him and that I was going to wiggle out of it.

If I had, my next move would have been to go after Victor because he was so sure about Tomica. That sounds exactly like the way a Traitor would act. It was the same way he behaved during the Chalice challenge, which I called out, but it didn’t make the edit. I was like, “This is Traitor behavior.” He was trying to command things. At that point, I think I could have turned people back against Victor if Wyatt had gone, but I never got the chance.

PC: Speaking of loyalty, it was really nice to see Katie stand by you at the final roundtable. Do you think that was a good strategic move, or will it hurt her in the end?
Joe: She was defending me, so I feel like it made sense given the narrative she had put forth for herself. But her not writing my name down meant everything in the world to me. It’s a testament to who she is as a human being. We talked afterward, and she was like, “Joe, I just couldn’t do it.” To have that relationship is amazing. A 23-year-old from Florida and a 44-year-old from Long Island bonding over this game.

PC: Going back to being a fan of the game, was there anyone you wanted to model your strategy after? Knowing that we’re going to get more seasons, if you were invited back, is there anything you’d do differently?
Joe: It’s funny because I gravitate toward personalities, regardless of their position in the game. I loved Ron Funches, even though he got a raw deal. He wasn’t afraid to speak his mind. Dylan Efron was another favorite of mine. Pilot Pete, too. Then, of course, you’ve got Cirie [Fields], Rob [Rausch], Parvati [Shallow], and Boston Rob. I knew I couldn’t be as cutthroat as some of those players, but I wanted to find a middle ground.

Now we’re going to manifest me getting back into that castle for an All-Stars season. I want to get there. If I do, I’d play the exact same way. I hope they make me a Traitor because I feel like a lot of people would say, “They’ll never make him a Traitor again. He’s too soft.” But that’s exactly what I want them to think.

To keep up with Joe, follow him on Instagram. The Traitors: New Blood is currently airing on NBC and available to stream the next day on Peacock.

Kevin

Kevin is a writer living in New York City. He is an enthusiast with an extensive movie collection, who enjoys attending numerous conventions throughout the year. Say hi on Twitter and Instagram!

Discussion about this post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.