Exclusive Interview: Nina Twine Discusses Her Strategy for Winning ‘The Anonymous,’ Adapting to the Twists, and Building Her Legacy

Nina Twine is stepping out of the shadow of her famous Survivor-winning mother, Sandra Diaz-Twine, and creating her own legacy with a thrilling win on The Anonymous. By mastering a game of strategy, social finesse, and sharp instincts, Nina has proven herself as a force to be reckoned with. Her ability to balance alliances, keep her identity hidden, and navigate each twist with impeccable timing has not only earned her the title but also set a new standard for future competitors.

Nina Twine’s path to victory on The Anonymous wasn’t just about navigating relationships—it was about mastering a game uniquely built on dual realities. The Anonymous is a high-stakes competition played in two worlds: the real world, where players engage face to face, and a digital world, where they communicate from behind a mask of anonymity in Anonymous Mode. In their private hideouts, players are free to say and do whatever it takes to advance, knowing that anonymity equals power, and the one who remains undetected gains the ultimate advantage. Straddling these two realities, contestants must play the ultimate game of perception and deception.

Pop Culturalist was lucky enough to speak with Nina about winning The Anonymous, adapting to the twists and players, and building her own legacy.

PC: You were so observant of the subtle details, whether it was how Jack [Usher] was tossing and turning at night or how people carried themselves. In that final face-off, what was it about Andy King’s reaction that tipped you off and made you realize he had picked the right box?
Nina: I’ve learned a lot from my past experiences, so I made sure to do some research. One of the main areas I focused on was body language. Andy is a very charismatic person, and I made it a point to observe that closely. But in that moment, I noticed he wasn’t displaying that charisma anymore. I wanted to come in trusting my instincts and the research I’d done, and it truly paid off. Observing everyone throughout the game from the start allowed me to pick up on these subtle changes. Without that, I wouldn’t have been able to catch on.

PC: That might actually be the answer to my next question, but since you competed on Survivor, was there anything you brought into this game that you didn’t realize going into your first season of that franchise? I feel like there are a lot of pitfalls that first-time players fall into that you avoided on The Anonymous.
Nina: Something I brought with me into The Anonymous from Survivor is the natural way people tend to gravitate towards me because of my own charisma, curiosity, and the way I approach others—I genuinely enjoy people and find them fascinating. I really focused on that. I wasn’t afraid to join or even interrupt conversations. But I also learned to reel in the chat a bit because I can sometimes say a little too much, which can raise unnecessary red flags. It was definitely a learning curve, but the moment I heard what The Anonymous was—a covert, deception game full of backstabbing and alliances, both in person and behind a handle—I knew this was tailor-made for me.

PC: There was a point in the game when Christopher [Shulstad] called you the “Silent Killer,” which feels spot on. Early on, you were flying under the radar without receiving any votes for nominations. Then, when you did, you started winning safety back to back. Even when the Anonymous had the chance to take you out, they didn’t. How did you minimize your threat level while making so many big moves?
Nina: I play from the shadows. I’m naturally talkative and charismatic, and people are drawn to that—they enjoy it. The closer I become to people, the harder it becomes for them to target me. It’s the same for me; if I become friends with someone, I hesitate and second-guess. So, I made sure to build connections with as many people as possible. I think they saw me as a friend or someone they got along with—a fun, quirky, talkative girl who’s also strategic but not overly threatening. That’s what I loved about The Anonymous: half of the game was behind the handle, allowing me to make moves without drawing attention too soon. Christopher eventually caught on and called me the “Silent Killer,” but it took him a while to get there, which was crucial. I knew how to work in the shadows, build strong relationships with the right people, and secure safety when I needed it most.

PC: At the end of each episode, the eliminated contestant reveals which avatar they used in Anonymous Mode. How much weight did you put into those reveals? How did that shift or alter your strategy?
Nina: I put some weight into those reveals because they gave me valuable information. Knowing their handle allowed me to track their voting patterns, decisions, and certain comments they made in the chat. This reverse research helped me identify blind spots and understand why I might not have connected certain dots. It allowed me to keep reevaluating—sometimes I’d feel confident about a handle, and other times I’d realize I needed to revisit it. It’s something I carried over from Survivor: the need to adapt constantly. Every day, I trusted myself to observe and stay ready to make adjustments to keep moving forward.

PC: What’s so fascinating about this competition series is the balance between building personal connections and knowing when to prioritize your game. In Survivor, the tribe decides who goes home, but here, every vote matters. Was there ever a point when you were the Anonymous, or if you’d had the chance later, where you considered eliminating someone like Dillian [Frelow] to better hide your identity?
Nina: If that situation had come up, absolutely, I would’ve considered it. There were definitely moments where I had to remind myself, “Nina, this is a game. You have to separate emotions from strategy.” I really enjoyed aligning with people who understood that boundary. We had a mutual respect; it’s not like we’d tell each other, “Hey, I’d vote you out,” but we knew the game came first. It wouldn’t have been easy, though—I probably would’ve been in my hideout, pulling my hair out! But when it comes to making tough decisions to reach the end, sometimes there’s no other choice.

PC: That’s what makes you a great game player—you can separate the two. Unlike Xavier [Prather], you managed to keep your identity hidden for much of the game. What was your game plan if Jack had come in more convinced that you were Sandra’s daughter, or even if someone like Wayne [Nichols] had figured it out?
Nina: If anyone had called me out as Sandra’s daughter, my planned response was, “What do your parents do? Let’s talk about everyone’s parents if that’s what we’re bringing up. I get it, but we’re two different individuals. Do you have a sibling everyone compares you to? How annoying is that? Or a best friend people constantly compare you with? It’s frustrating, isn’t it? So, let’s not do that.” I would have tailored it depending on who I was talking to; some people respond to directness, while others need a relatable comparison. That would’ve been my argument, and I hope it would have worked. Thankfully, I didn’t have to go there.

PC: It’s also interesting that on Survivor, you competed against returning players. In this game, though, most are first-timers. How different is that experience?
Nina: Players with experience are ready to get into the nitty-gritty from the start—no need for the fluff of prolonged introductions. Building bonds is still important, but with them, it only takes a day or a quick conversation to set that foundation, and they’re ready to jump to strategy.

With new players, you have to sort through who’s really ready to dive in. Some people genuinely want you to get to know them, while others are itching to get the game moving. I’m confident in my ability to read those differences, whether it’s a first-time player or a returner.

PC: As the first season of The Anonymous, you set the standard for how this game will be played moving forward. Which part of your strategy played the biggest role in securing your win? What do you hope future players take from your game?
Nina: Timing is everything. Throughout the season, we saw players succeed when they acted at the right moment, and others miss the mark when they didn’t. Timing is crucial, and so is having confidence in yourself. Don’t be afraid to take action—you may not know the outcome until later, but at least you’ll be confident in your decisions. Another key aspect is knowing how to approach each player. You saw me balance multiple conversations. Dillian was my number one, so I’d give him a heads-up if people were talking about him. I’d do the same with Christopher or Jack but in different ways, based on what each person needed to hear. It’s about sharing information carefully so it doesn’t backfire. Every relationship mattered, and knowing how much to reveal to each person kept my game intact.

To keep up with Nina, follow her on Instagram. Binge-watch The Anonymous on Peacock today.