‘The Traitors: New Blood’ Exit Interview: Morgan Cook on Her Quiet Strategy and the Move She Never Got to Make

Morgan Cook

Morgan Cook built an audience of more than 1.2 million Instagram followers by turning the anxious thoughts many people keep to themselves into sharp, relatable comedy. Known for whispering her inner monologue through her “whispers of insanity” videos, the Chicago-based content creator has made a career out of helping people feel seen. On The Traitors: New Blood, that same instinct for quietly observing everything around her became the foundation of her game.

Rather than command the roundtable, Morgan remained consistent, shared information when it mattered, and quietly tracked the players who raised her suspicions. By the time the Faithfuls began gaining momentum, she had assembled a compelling case against Joe Vanella and even memorized the speech she planned to deliver at the next roundtable. But before she could reveal how much she had pieced together, Joe made the first move and murdered her.

Pop Culturalist chatted with Morgan Cook about the quiet strategy that carried her through the game, the clues that led her to Joe, why the Faithfuls struggled to unite against him, and what stepping into the castle taught her about her own strength and blind spots.

PC: In your pregame interviews, you talked about quietly observing, sharing information gradually, and not being the loudest voice at the roundtable. That approach seemed to serve you really well in the game, but it’s a tricky line to walk. As we saw with Sherry [Kuehl] and Victor [Vollbrechthausen], staying too quiet or speaking too much can both raise suspicions. How did you find that balance, and when did you know it was the right time to share what you were picking up on?
Morgan: I tried to be very consistent with how much I spoke up. Sherry was a yapper when we weren’t at the roundtable, so when we got there and she was much quieter, it raised suspicions. I was pretty much just as quiet during the regular game as I was at the roundtable.

Whenever I felt like I had a point worth sharing, I would speak up. But I was never really trying to be the person who threw a name out there. I wanted to support whoever I thought was right at the time.

PC: That consistency got you really far in the game. You were all finally able to catch a Traitor with Tomica Adams’ banishment. Did that lend more credibility to Victor Vollbrechthausen’s Fruitgate theory, or did you think it was a shot in the dark that happened to hit its target?
Morgan: I pushed back against the fruit theory until my last breath. I thought it was like the Yam Yam situation with Lisa Rinna last season, where he was right but wrong about how it happened. I thought this was a similar situation, but I have to eat my words. Victor was totally right. By that point, I felt confident that he was a Faithful. He wasn’t on my radar as a Traitor anymore, but I was still like, “It’s not the fruit, bro.”

PC: That’s so funny, too. In the moment, what did you make of Joe [Vanella] throwing the fruit at you? Even without Victor’s theory, did you ever consider switching your glass as a precaution?
Morgan: I didn’t consider switching my glass. I really didn’t think it was going to be me. I would have eliminated somebody who was very clearly a Faithful, like Abbey [Benjamin] or Clyde [Moser]. Honestly, at that point, a lot of us thought Victor was a Faithful, too.

By then, I assumed Joe was a Traitor. I thought, “If I were Joe, getting rid of Victor might actually be better than keeping him.” If you keep him, he’ll probably continue coming after you the same way he did with Tomica. At least if you get rid of him, you can say, “I was framed,” and defend yourself without him interrupting.

I also thought Joe had a decent argument he could have used against me. Because I had defended Tomica, he could have said, “You’re all saying I defended her, but Morgan defended her, too.” There also seemed to be an argument forming against Wyatt [Gillespie]. If Joe had gotten rid of Victor, there were so many different directions he could have taken the conversation that eliminating Victor seemed like the obvious choice to me. But I was incorrect.

PC: As you get into the later stages of the game, you start to wonder why the Traitors are keeping you around. Abby [Lee] shared that, the night before she was murdered, the two of you had a conversation in which you admitted you suspected each other, but neither of you put the other’s name forward at the roundtable. What was your thinking behind that decision? Did her murder change the way you viewed your own position in the game?
Morgan: I was definitely suspicious of Abby L. for the majority of the time she was there. I believe I voted for Wyatt that night, even though I didn’t think it was Wyatt at all. When Abby said his name, I was like, “You’re either a Traitor, or this strategy just isn’t working for you,” because I didn’t think Wyatt was a Traitor.

But I didn’t know whose name to write down. The roundtable that night was chaotic, and so many names were being thrown out. I knew Abby was going to write down Wyatt, and if she was a Traitor, I wanted her to think I was still with her.

PC: It also felt like the Faithfuls were finally building momentum as the game entered its second half. Unfortunately, we didn’t get to see how you would have approached the endgame. What was your strategy moving forward? Did you suspect Joe and Katie [Fites], and were you hoping to be recruited?
Morgan: I was pretty adamant about Joe at that point, and I suspected Katie as well. I think I made that known to both of them. I brought it up at a couple of roundtables, and I thought that might protect me if I was right about them because, if they murdered me, the suspicion could come back on them. But I don’t think I was public enough with my suspicions for them to be too worried. I know that’s why they killed me because Joe told me.

If I had survived that night, I was ready to go after Joe. I had a speech memorized for the roundtable. I was ready to take him out. That was the third phase of my strategy. I had been observing the entire time, and I had a good idea of who I thought was who. That was when I planned to show that I was willing to speak up and that I might have been more aware of what was happening than people realized. [sighs] But I never reached that point because Joe got me first.

PC: Tell us more about the speech you had planned because I felt like you were picking up on so many subtle clues throughout the game.
Morgan: The first time I started keeping track of Joe was after Xavier [Scruggs] was murdered. Joe had been with X the night before, so at first, I thought Joe might have been recruited and was babysitting his recruit. That was when I first thought, “I’m going to pay a little more attention to Joe.”

Then there was the Death Parade challenge when we were in the cages. When he got into the last cage, I thought, “I feel like a Traitor is going to get into this cage.” If you’re a Faithful and you’ve reached the final gate, you’re going to think, “This is all I have to get through, and then I’m completely safe.” I would have been adamant about not getting into the cage at that point. I felt like a Traitor would get in so we could wrap up the challenge without anyone noticing, and Joe got in at the end. I took note of that.

More generally, he was always talking about how competitive he was and how frustrated he felt that we weren’t catching Traitors. But when you asked him who he thought was a Traitor, he would say, “I don’t know.” I was like, “What do you mean you don’t know?” That’s an acceptable answer at the beginning of the game, but halfway through, you have to have an opinion. Victor asked him the same question at the roundtable, and all he could come up with was Tomica. Those were probably my biggest pieces of evidence.

He also voted for Wyatt at one point, which I thought was a really strange throwaway vote for someone who wanted to win so badly. It was all those little things that added up in my head, and none of them involved an apple.

PC: That’s a compelling case from start to finish. What’s so interesting is that nearly everyone I’ve spoken to in their exit interviews suspected Joe was a Traitor, but they didn’t feel like they had the numbers to banish him. Why weren’t you all able to come together and say, “Joe is on everyone’s radar. Why aren’t we voting for him?”
Morgan: We didn’t talk about it with each other. Joe was like the dad of the castle, and everyone loved him. In the back of everyone’s mind, we were thinking, “If I bring up Joe, it’s going to piss people off.” Everyone had such a good relationship with him.

It was also one of those situations where you think, “If I believe you’re a Traitor, maybe I’ll keep you around longer in the hope that you’ll keep me safe.” I also think we all hoped he wasn’t a Traitor because we loved him so much.

PC: He built so much social capital. On a more personal note, I think one of the most moving scenes of the season is when you’re all sitting around the table sharing your whys for being there. Can you tell us a bit more about your own why and what you ultimately took away from this experience?
Morgan: I wanted to do this experience to challenge myself. It meant putting myself out there in a way I never had before. I’ve always tried to do that in my life. I’ve never wanted my anxiety or introverted tendencies to hold me back from experiences I think I would genuinely enjoy, even if they might be scary.

When I was picked for the show, I thought, “This is really horrifying.” [laughs] But I also knew it was going to be so cool. I was going to meet so many amazing people, and I knew I would be so happy that I did it, regardless of how it turned out. That was really my why for wanting to do it.

In terms of what I took away, I proved to myself that I’m capable of a lot more than I probably thought I was. I also learned a lot about my blind spots because they get magnified in this game. In real life, I’m often suspicious of people who are nice to me. I’m like, “What do you want? Do you really like me?” [laughs]

In the game, I was suspicious of the people I was closest to. I was suspicious of Michael [Foote] and Abby L., and they were my two closest people. With Michael specifically, I thought, “I think he’s trying to form a bond with me so that when he murders me, it won’t get traced back to him.” That wasn’t the case at all. He was genuinely a nice guy who liked me. We vibed. I walked away thinking, “We should talk about that in therapy.” [laughs] The game challenges you and reveals things about yourself that you don’t normally see in everyday life, which I didn’t expect.

To keep up with Morgan, follow her on Instagram. The Traitors: New Blood is currently airing on NBC and available to stream the next day on Peacock.

Kevin

Kevin is a writer living in New York City. He is an enthusiast with an extensive movie collection, who enjoys attending numerous conventions throughout the year. Say hi on Twitter and Instagram!

Discussion about this post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.