Categories: FilmReviews

To See or Not to See: Batman v. Superman

It’s supposed to be “the greatest gladiator match in the history of the world” according to Lex Luthor. But, does Batman v. Superman live up to the hype?

Despite being slaughtered by critics, the film made a record-breaking $170.1 million in North America and an additional $254 million overseas. I have a hunch #SadAffleck is pretty happy right now. While there’s a lot wrong with the film, it isn’t as bad as early reviews would lead you to believe.

Batman v. Superman picks up after the epic fight scene between Superman (Henry Cavill) and General Zod in Man of Steel. I know what you’re thinking. And, no, this isn’t the sequel. We quickly learn that one of the buildings destroyed in the battle—along with the civilians in it—belongs to Bruce Wayne (Ben Affleck).

Bruce fears that the Man of Steel is not held accountable for his actions. And, he decides to take matters into his own hands. While the two iconic superheroes face off, a new threat, Doomsday, is created by Lex Luthor. Batman and Superman must put their differences aside to save the world.

The reasoning behind the conflict is logical. But, it could have been fleshed out with better direction. Christopher Nolan and Bryan Singer come to mind. Snyder’s directorial style is sloppy and disjointed. It’s hard to be fully engaged at the start because the first half-hour jumps from character to character. It’s a tangled web that’s often confusing but comes together by the conclusion of the film.

It’s a shame since the cast was pretty outstanding. Remember when the internet had a meltdown after Ben Affleck was cast as Batman? Well, they’re probably eating their words now. He does a fine job in the film bringing forth a grittier Batman. He’s no Christian Bale but that’s an unfair comparison. And, Henry Cavill IS Superman. I can’t imagine anyone else playing the role. Well, maybe Dean Cain circa 1993. If you liked him in Man of Steel, you’ll love him here. But the real standout in the film is Gal Gadot. Many moviegoers have stated her character is unnecessary for the film. And, I wholeheartedly agree. But, she proves she’s more than capable of carrying her own spinoff in 2017. She’s a strong, brilliant heroine who kicks ass.

Another moment in the film that I quite enjoyed was the introduction of The Flash (Ezra Miller), Cyborg (Ray Fisher), and Aquaman (Jason Momoa) aka The Justice League. Again, with better direction it could have been a game-changer in the film. Instead, it’s receiving mixed reviews (much like the film).

All in all, I would recommend seeing the film. Is it entertaining and action-packed? Yes. Is it one of the better films in its genre? No.

★ ★ ★ out of 4

Header Photo Credit: Clay Enos/Warner Bros.

Kevin

Kevin is a writer living in New York City. He is an enthusiast with an extensive movie collection, who enjoys attending numerous conventions throughout the year. Say hi on Twitter and Instagram!

View Comments

Recent Posts

Exclusive Interview: How The Parenting’s Dean Norris Took That Scene to the Next Level

Craig Johnson’s The Parenting delivers the perfect blend of horror and hilarity, turning a classic…

1 day ago

Exclusive Interview: Director Craig Johnson and Writer Kent Sublette on Balancing Horror, Comedy, and Heart in ‘The Parenting’

Meeting the in-laws is stressful enough—throw in a 400-year-old poltergeist, and things go completely off…

2 days ago

SXSW 2025: Florence Hunt and Rory Walton-Smith on ‘Mix Tape,’ First Love, and Their Artistic Process

First love is unforgettable. It leaves an imprint, shaping the way we see the world,…

2 days ago

SXSW 2025: Siobhan McCarthy, Misha Osherovich, and Nico Carney on Reclaiming Comedy Classics with Trans Inclusion in ‘She’s the He’

Comedy classics like Mean Girls, She’s the Man, and Clueless have shaped generations with their…

3 days ago

Daring, Unpredictable, and Unforgettable: Tyler Cornack’s ‘Mermaid’ Dives into SXSW 2025 with Stars Johnny Pemberton and Avery Potemri

To say Tyler Cornack is a visionary would be an understatement. His fearless approach to…

4 days ago